Texas AI Docket

Articles · Education

Since December 2023 a TEA scoring engine has read English STAAR written answers first, and reading rescore requests rose from 2,758 in spring 2024 to 64,489 this spring

A Texas Education Agency engine scores written STAAR answers first. This spring districts asked for far more human rescores, and people raised thousands of reading scores.

Read the story

The Texas Education Agency began using an automated scoring engine in December 2023 to grade open-ended questions on STAAR. As the agency described its hybrid model then, the engine scores written responses first and at least 25 percent of them are also routed to human scorers. Where a person scores an answer, that score is the score of record.

Written answers on Spanish language STAAR tests are scored entirely by people and never by the engine. TEA says the engine is programmed on a sample of about 3,000 human scored field test responses. It describes the engine as a closed database whose student answers only TEA can access.

Why the agency uses it

STAAR now leaves TEA with many times more constructed responses to grade each year. A TEA spokesperson said scoring the essays by hand would cost an additional $15 million to $20 million a year. It would also take four to five times as many human scorers. The spokesperson described the result as a system that keeps human judgment at the center of scoring.

What districts did

In spring 2024 the state received 2,758 requests to regrade open-ended answers on reading exams. The next year it received 21,620. This spring the count reached 64,489, the Texas Tribune reported on October 7th.

People conducted every rescore, and TEA sends each rescore request for human scoring. The state raised more than 13,300 reading scores after the reviews. Across all open-ended responses on reading exams, fewer than half of one percent changed.

Dallas ISD submitted more than 5,100 reading tests for rescoring, and 34%% came back with a higher score.

What it costs to ask, and what is not known

A district pays $50 per test when it asks for a rescore and the score does not change. TEA waives the fee when the score changes.

The 2026 counts come from the Texas Tribune's reporting, and no TEA page with them was available when this was checked. The agency's description of the design comes from its December 2023 and March 2024 documents, so whether every detail still holds this spring is not established here. The reporting does not say the engine was wrong about any one student's answer. It shows how often districts asked for a person and how often a person raised the score.

Sources for this story

Claim-by-claim verification · 26 claims
  1. In spring 2024 the state received 2,758 requests to regrade open-ended response scores on STAAR reading exams.

    In spring 2024, the state had 2,758 requests to regrade open-ended response scores on reading exams.

    Texas Tribune, Megan Menchaca, October 7th, STAAR rescoring requests triple after more Texas schools question computer grading · Checked November 17th, 2026

  2. The Tribune counts 21,620 regrade requests in the year before this spring.

    Then, 21,620 requests last year.

    Texas Tribune, Megan Menchaca, October 7th, STAAR rescoring requests triple after more Texas schools question computer grading · Checked November 17th, 2026

  3. This spring the number of regrade requests reached 64,489.

    This spring, that jumped to 64,489.

    Texas Tribune, Megan Menchaca, October 7th, STAAR rescoring requests triple after more Texas schools question computer grading · Checked November 17th, 2026

  4. The state raised more than 13,300 reading scores after the reviews.

    The state improved more than 13,300 reading scores after the reviews.

    Texas Tribune, Megan Menchaca, October 7th, STAAR rescoring requests triple after more Texas schools question computer grading · Checked November 17th, 2026

  5. Fewer than .5% of all open-ended responses on reading exams had a score change.

    In total, less than .5% of total open-ended responses on reading exams saw changes.

    Texas Tribune, Megan Menchaca, October 7th, STAAR rescoring requests triple after more Texas schools question computer grading · Checked November 17th, 2026

  6. A district pays $50 per test for a rescore that leaves the student's score unchanged.

    School districts must pay $50 per test if they request rescoring and the student’s score does not change.

    Texas Tribune, Megan Menchaca, October 7th, STAAR rescoring requests triple after more Texas schools question computer grading · Checked November 17th, 2026

  7. Every rescore was done by a human scorer.

    Humans conducted all re-scores.

    Texas Tribune, Megan Menchaca, October 7th, STAAR rescoring requests triple after more Texas schools question computer grading · Checked November 17th, 2026

  8. Dallas ISD sent more than 5,100 reading tests for rescoring and 34% came back with a higher score.

    In total, the district submitted more than 5,100 reading tests for rescoring, and 34% returned with a higher score.

    Texas Tribune, Megan Menchaca, October 7th, STAAR rescoring requests triple after more Texas schools question computer grading · Checked November 17th, 2026

  9. TEA began grading open-ended questions with an automated scoring engine in December 2023.

    The Texas Education Agency began using an automated scoring engine in December 2023 to grade open-ended questions

    Texas Tribune, Megan Menchaca, October 7th, STAAR rescoring requests triple after more Texas schools question computer grading · Checked November 17th, 2026

  10. A TEA spokesperson said scoring the essays by hand would cost an additional $15 million to $20 million per year.

    cost an additional $15 million to $20 million per year

    Texas Tribune, Megan Menchaca, October 7th, STAAR rescoring requests triple after more Texas schools question computer grading · Checked November 17th, 2026

  11. The same spokesperson said hand scoring would take four to five times as many human scorers.

    four to five times the number of human scorers

    Texas Tribune, Megan Menchaca, October 7th, STAAR rescoring requests triple after more Texas schools question computer grading · Checked November 17th, 2026

  12. TEA spokesperson Jake Kobersky described the system as one that keeps human judgment at the center of scoring.

    The result is a system that keeps human judgment at the center of scoring

    Texas Tribune, Megan Menchaca, October 7th, STAAR rescoring requests triple after more Texas schools question computer grading · Checked November 17th, 2026

  13. As of December 2023 TEA's hybrid model had an automated scoring engine score written responses first, then sent at least 25 percent to human scorers.

    This means that the responses are initially scored by an automated scoring engine (ASE) and at least 25 percent of student responses are then routed to human scorers.

    TEA Student Assessment Division, Scoring Process for STAAR Constructed Responses, December 2023 · Checked November 17th, 2026

  14. TEA sends every rescore request to a human scorer.

    Rescore requests are sent for human scoring.

    TEA Student Assessment Division, Scoring Process for STAAR Constructed Responses, December 2023 · Checked November 17th, 2026

  15. TEA waives the rescore fee when the score on the question changes.

    If the score on the constructed-response question changes, the fee is waived.

    TEA Student Assessment Division, Scoring Process for STAAR Constructed Responses, December 2023 · Checked November 17th, 2026

  16. Written responses on the Spanish STAAR tests are scored entirely by humans and never by the engine.

    Student responses to SCR and ECR questions for STAAR Spanish assessments are 100 percent human scored and do not get scored by the ASE.

    TEA Student Assessment Division, Scoring Process for STAAR Constructed Responses, December 2023 · Checked November 17th, 2026

  17. When a response is sent to a human, the human's score becomes the score of record.

    Any student responses that are routed for human scoring maintain the score assigned by the human scorer as the score of record.

    TEA Student Assessment Division, Scoring Process for STAAR Constructed Responses, December 2023 · Checked November 17th, 2026

  18. In March 2024 TEA said keeping full human scoring would have cost $15-20M more per year.

    maintaining full human scoring would have cost $15-20M more per year

    TEA, Hybrid Scoring Key Questions, March 2024 · Checked November 17th, 2026

  19. TEA said the redesigned STAAR left it with 6-7x more constructed responses to grade each year.

    With 6-7x more constructed responses to grade annually for STAAR

    TEA, Hybrid Scoring Key Questions, March 2024 · Checked November 17th, 2026

  20. For each question the engine is programmed on a sample of about 3,000 human scored field test responses.

    The engine uses a sample of ~3,000 human scored responses from the field test for programming.

    TEA, Hybrid Scoring Key Questions, March 2024 · Checked November 17th, 2026

  21. The switch from fully human scoring to hybrid scoring began in December 2023.

    The hybrid scoring transition started in December 2023, and student responses went from fully human scoring to hybrid scoring.

    TEA, Hybrid Scoring Key Questions, March 2024 · Checked November 17th, 2026

  22. Under hybrid scoring every written response passes through the auto scoring engine and 25% are also scored twice by humans.

    All scores go through auto scoring engine; 25% are double human scored

    TEA, Hybrid Scoring Key Questions, March 2024 · Checked November 17th, 2026

  23. TEA describes its engine as a closed database rather than AI that teaches itself.

    Instead, the automated scoring engine is a closed database with student response data accessible only by TEA

    TEA, Hybrid Scoring Key Questions, March 2024 · Checked November 17th, 2026

  24. TEA officials said about 27,200 students received additional credit on text responses in the STAAR reading test after an annual agency review.

    Texas Education Agency officials said Friday about 27,200 students received additional credit for their text responses

    Texas Tribune, Megan Menchaca, September 4th, After rescoring STAAR exams, 11 Texas districts seeing A-F grades improve · Checked November 17th, 2026

  25. Nine campuses and five districts got higher A-F ratings from that review.

    Nine campuses and five districts saw their A-F rating increases as a result, officials said.

    Texas Tribune, Megan Menchaca, September 4th, After rescoring STAAR exams, 11 Texas districts seeing A-F grades improve · Checked November 17th, 2026

  26. About 1.7% of more than 1.6 million exams reviewed saw their scores go up.

    About 1.7% of more than 1.6 million exams reviewed saw scores improve

    Texas Tribune, Megan Menchaca, September 4th, After rescoring STAAR exams, 11 Texas districts seeing A-F grades improve · Checked November 17th, 2026